Comparative Study of the Epistemological Foundations of Technical and Non-Technical Curriculum Models with an Emphasis on Virtual Education

Document Type : Research

Authors

1 PhD Student, Department of Educational Studies and Curriculum Planning, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran.

2 Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Payame Noor University, Tehran, Iran.

3 Assistant Professor, Department of Educational Sciences, Science and Research Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

The approach of the present research, which aims to compare the epistemological foundations of technical and non-technical curriculum models, has been a qualitative comparative strategy. The researcher, using a descriptive-analytical method and relying on the theoretical framework of critical discourse analysis and Norman Fairclough's theory, has sought to reveal the intellectual framework of curriculum theorists in light of the social conditions. Over time, due to the importance of curriculum planning in education and training, various approaches and trends have emerged in this field, which are generally categorized under two titles: technical scientific approaches and non-scientific non-technical approaches. To answer the research question, four epistemological questions raised regarding the types of technical and non-technical curriculum models. The results showed that knowledge was rational/relative in technical rational patterns and in non-technical patterns. The technical patterns and the views of figures such as Tyler and Taba, and the distance between them and the views of Pinar and Eisner, reflect the gap between two epistemological systems: idealism and pragmatism. Since virtual education has features such as flexibility, motivation, independence, interaction with content, and interaction with individuals, it is suggested to curriculum planners and educational systems to design new approaches, methods, and models that can logically integrate epistemology with modern curriculum patterns.

Keywords

Main Subjects

References

Ababaf, Zahra and Painar, William. (2019). A Reflection on Understanding Curriculum and Pedagogy from the Perspective of Instructors: A Case Study of the Department of Curriculum and Pedagogy at the University of British Columbia, Quarterly Journal of Higher Education Curriculum Studies, Year 10, Issue 20, Autumn and Winter 2019, 57-84.
Fathi Vajargah, Kourosh. (2017). Concepts and Principles of Curriculum Planning, Tehran: Science of Masters.
Ghasemi, Fatemeh, Ali Asgari, Majid, Niknam, Zahra, Amani Tehrani, Mahmoud. (2022). Evaluation of the New Physics Curriculum in Practice: A Study Based on Expertise and Eisner's Educational Critique, Journal of Curriculum Studies in Iran, Volume Seventeen, Issue 66, Pages 177-210.
Gotak, Gerald Al. (2012). Philosophical Schools and Educational Ideas. Translated by Pak Sarasht, Mohammad Jafar, Tehran: Samt.
Hashemi, Seyyed Ahmad, Shamsai, Abbas Ali, and Ahmadzadeh, Hossein. (2023). Examination of Epistemological Foundations in the Curriculum, Eighth Scientific Conference on New Approaches in Human Sciences of Iran, Ilam, https://civilica.com/doc/1906903
Karami Shirazi, Nasruddin and Hashemi, Seyyed Ahmad and Ranjbar, Mokhtar. (2019). Examination of Curriculum Design Patterns in Educational Activities, Second National Conference on Curriculum Transformation, Lamerd.
Kazemi, Seyedeh Fatemeh, Hashemi, Soheila, Khabazi Kenari, Mehdi. (2017). Analysis of the Ontological and Epistemological Approaches of University Professors in the Teaching Process. Quarterly Journal of Higher Education Curriculum Studies 8(15), 61-90.
Khosravi, Rahmatollah and Kafi Zadeh, Mansoureh (2012). An Analysis of Tyler's Logic in Curriculum Planning: Justified and Overlooked Themes. Journal of Educational Sciences. Volume 5. Issue 18. Pages 67-88.
Madani, Seyyed Ahmad (1399). A Look at the Professional Path of Ralph Tyler: A Historical Narrative of a Lifetime Effort to Connect "Theory" and "Practice" in Curriculum, Journal: Research in Curriculum Planning (Knowledge and Research in Educational Sciences - Curriculum Planning), Volume 17, Issue 40, pp. 1-20.
Mahroozadeh, Tayebe (2010) Designing the Curriculum and Its Dimensions from the Perspectives of Eisner and Zais. Quarterly Journal of Research in Education and Training, 1. 2010; 2 (24): 67-89
Mehr Mohammadi, Mahmoud (2004) Curriculum and Perspectives, Approaches, and Outlooks. Publication by Behnashr Astan Quds Razavi.
Mehrjou, Parvaneh and Sarmadi, Mohammad Reza (2022) The Nature of Philosophical Foundations of Teaching in Teaching-Learning Strategies, Theory and Practice in the Curriculum of the Tenth Grade, Spring and Summer 2022, Issue 19
Naghibzadeh, Mir Abdolhossein. (2012) A Look at the Philosophical Perspectives of the Twentieth Century. Tehran: Tahouri Publications.
Qadri, Mostafa (2013) Historical analysis of the meanings and purposes of postmodernism in the field of curriculum studies, Quarterly Journal of Theory and Practice in Curriculum, Volume 1, Issue 1, Spring and Summer 2013, pp. 49-72.
Safarifard, Razieh and Hajazi, Elaheh and Zanganeh, Amirhossein and Gholamali Lavasani, Masoud. (2024). Investigating the Teaching-Learning Process in an Electronic Environment: A Mixed Study at the University of Tehran. Scientific Journal of Research in School and Virtual Learning, 12(1), 45-58.
Samadi, Parvin (2012) Hilda Taba, Iranian Encyclopedia of Curriculum Studies.
Samadi, Parvin (2104) Analysis of Tyler's Perspective in Curriculum, Iranian Encyclopedia of Curriculum.
Talebi, Saeed, Mazloumian, Saeed, Saeef, Mohammad Hassan (2010) Principles of Curriculum. Tehran: Payame Noor University Press.
Talebzadeh Nobarian, Mohsen and Fathi Vajarghah, Kourosh (2003) Specialized Topics in Curriculum Planning. Tehran: Ayizh
Yaqoobi, Javad. Malek Mohammadi, Akbar. Iravani, Homayoun. Attaran, Mahmoud. (2018). Desirable characteristics of students and faculty members in e-learning in higher education in Iran: Perspectives of students in virtual courses. Journal of Research and Planning in Higher Education, Issue 47.
Asareh, Alireza. (2019). Introduction to Eisner's Perspective, Iranian Encyclopedia of Curriculum.
Rahmani Boldaji, Maryam, Saberi, Maryam, Mohammadi, Farhad. (2015). Who was Hilda Taba, what did she say and what did she do? Collection of articles from the first international conference on psychology and educational sciences, Shiraz, May 2015.
Sarmadi, Mohammad Reza, Saif, Mohammad Hassan, Talebi, Saeed (2011). Theoretical and Philosophical Foundations of Distance Education, Tehran: Payame Noor University.
Shabani, Hassan. (2010). Educational and Developmental Skills, Tehran: Samt Publications
Shalian, Rahim, Saidi Rezvani, Mahmoud, Amin Yazdi, Seyed Amir, Karshaki, Hossein, and Asghari Nikah, Seyed Mohsen. (2015). A Reflection on the Role of the Model in the Domain of Curriculum Design. Research Journal of Educational Foundations (Educational and Psychological Studies of Mashhad), 5(2), 153-172.
Shiyvandi Cheliche, Kamran and Hasanvand, Fazlollah and Abdolmaleki, Saeed and Mohammadi, Masoumeh. (2022). Construction and validation of a questionnaire for purposeful management of virtual classroom. Scientific Journal of Research in School and Virtual Learning, 10(3), 23-34.
Boon, M., Orozco, M. & Sivakumar, K. Epistemological and educational issues in teaching practice-oriented scientific research: roles for philosophers of science. Euro Jnl Phil Sci 12, 16 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s13194-022-00447-z
Dunbar, Ronan & Buckley, Jeffrey & Seery, Niall. (2019). Curriculum development in technology teacher education: Integrating epistemology, pedagogy and capability.
Eisner, Elliot W. (1994). The educational imagination: on the design and evaluation of school programs. New York: Macmillan.
Felder, R.M., and Brent, R., (2005)."Understanding Student Differences," J. Engr. Education, Vol. 94, No 1, ,pp. 57-72Understanding- Differences. pdf.
Finder, M. (2004). Educating America: How Ralph W. Tyler Taught America to Teach. Westport, Connecticut: Praeger
Green, H. J., & Hood, M. (2013). Significance of Epistemological Beliefs for Teaching and Learning Psychology: A Review. Psychology Learning & Teaching, 12(2), 168-178. https://doi.org/10.2304/plat.2013.12.2.168
Harasim, L. (2017). Learning Theories: The Role of Epistemology, Science, and Technology. In: Spector, M., Lockee, B., Childress, M. (eds) Learning, Design, and Technology. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-17727-4_48-1
Hlebowitsh, P.S. (1995). Interpretations of the Tyler Rationale: A reply to Kliebard. Journal of Curriculum Studies.27(1), pp(89-94).
Kridel, C., & Bullough, Jr., R. V. (2007). Stories of the Eight- Year Study. New York: State University of New York Press.
Lee, J.W. (2010). Online Support Service quality, Online Learning Acceptance, and Student Satisfaction. Internet and Higher Education, 13, 277–283.
Moore, J, L. Deane,C,D. Galyen,K. (2011). E-learning, Online Learning, And Distance Learning environments: Are they The Same? Internet and Higher Education, 14, 129–135.
Pinar, W. F., & Grumet, M. R. (1976). Toward a poor curriculum. Dubuque, IA: Kendall/Hunt.
Pinar, W.F. (1980). Reply to my Critics. Curriculum Inquiry 10 (2),199-205.
Pinar, William, F. (2008). What Is Curriculum Theory? Taylor & Francis e-Library.
Ridings, J. (1981, November). An interview with Ralph Tyler [Occasional papers, No. 13]. Retrieved, May 15, 2004 from the web site of Western Michigan University, Evaluation Center.
Schubert, W., & Schubert, A. L. L. (1986). A dialog with Ralph Tyler. Journal of Thought, 21(1), 91–118.
Seery, N., Phelan, J., Buckley, J. et al. Epistemological treatment of design in technology education. Int J Technol Des Educ 33, 1547–1561 (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10798-022-09781-y
Siegel, H. (2020). Why Does Epistemology Matter in Education?. In: Peters, M. (eds) Encyclopedia of Educational Philosophy and Theory. Springer, Singapore. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-981-287-532-7_687-3
Siemens, G. (2004a) Connectivism: A learning theory for a digital age. International Journal of Instructional Technology and Distance Learning, 2(1), pp. 1-13,2004.
Tanner, D. (1982). Curriculum history. In H.E. Mitzel (Ed.), Encylopedia of educational research (pp. 412- 420). New York: Macmillian and Free Press.
Tariq Mehmood Bhuttah, Chen Xiaoduan, Hakim Ullah, Amna Bibi; Curriculum Development: “An Analysis of The Tyler and Taba Model”; 2018: 1 (7): 109-118
Tyler, R. (1949). Basic principles of curriculum and instruction. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Wang, V., Torrisi-Steele, G., & Reinsfield, E. (2021). Transformative learning, epistemology and technology in adult education. Journal of Adult and Continuing Education, 27(2), 324-340. https://doi.org/10.1177/1477971420918602

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics